The Great American Rights Bake Off: Freedom of Religion v. Freedom from Discrimination

Authors

Chelsea Ebin
J. Ricky Price, St. John Fisher UniversityFollow

Document Type

Book Chapter

Publication Date

2023

Abstract

Progressive actors are losing the battle to protect LGBT and reproductive rights from conservative claims of a right to religious discrimination. Increasingly, we are witnessing legal challenges premised on the ground that religious actors’ First Amendment rights and women’s and LGBT rights to equal protection and public accommodation are in conflict. This article contextualizes so-called “competing rights” claims within a longer political and legal history. We utilize a discursive institutionalist framework to assess the strategies used both by conservative political actors promoting a “competing rights” agenda and by LGBT activists focused on narrative change and marriage equality. Finding the limited strategy adopted by marriage equality activists cannot effectively withstand the legal challenge mounted by those claiming “competing rights,” we propose a new strategy for resistance premised on a strict interpretation of church/state separation and suggest a strategy for preserving and expanding public accommodation law through the creation of intersectional coalitions.

Comments

Find this book at your library.

Purchase this book on Amazon.

Publication Information

Ebin, Chelsea and Price, J. Ricky (2023). "The Great American Rights Bake Off: Freedom of Religion v. Freedom from Discrimination." Tactics and Emancipation in the Age of Authoritarian Neoliberalism , 84-.

Please note that the Publication Information provides general citation information and may not be appropriate for your discipline. To receive help in creating a citation based on your discipline, please visit https://libguides.sjf.edu/citations.